The pros and cons of AI in customer service

As artificial intelligence (AI) continues to transform industries, its impact on customer service is significant. From streamlining interactions to providing 24/7 support, AI systems offer undeniable benefits — however, they don’t come without their drawbacks.

In this blog post, we’ll examine the pros and cons of AI in customer service, focusing on the challenges you might face when implementing it in your own operations.

What is AI in customer service?

AI plays a pivotal role in modern customer service by automating routine interactions, analyzing customer data, and quickly resolving common issues. Applications like chatbots, automated call centers, and recommendation engines have become standard tools for many businesses — enabling them to instantly answer frequently asked questions or analyze customer data and offer personalized product suggestions.

While these tools offer undeniable advantages, they also come with limitations that businesses must consider before fully integrating AI into their customer service strategies.

Advantages of AI in customer service

AI has become an indispensable tool for businesses looking to improve their customer service. Here’s a more detailed exploration of the key benefits AI brings to the table.

1. Enhanced efficiency

• Use case: AI-driven tools excel at automating repetitive tasks, such as answering FAQs, processing returns, or scheduling appointments. These tasks, while necessary, can take up a significant portion of a human agent’s time.
• Example: Chatbots can immediately address inquiries like, “What are your business hours?” or “Where is my order?” — questions that might otherwise clog service queues.
• Benefit: By handling them efficiently, AI allows human agents to focus on more complex and nuanced issues, ensuring that customers with unique problems receive the attention they need.

2. 24/7 availability

• Use case: One of AI’s most appealing features is its ability to provide support around the clock. Unlike human agents, AI systems don’t require breaks, sleep, or holidays, ensuring customers always have help when they need it.
• Example: A customer booking flights late at night can receive immediate assistance from an AI-powered chatbot, improving their overall experience and preventing potential frustration.
• Benefit: Businesses with global operations can use AI to respond to customers from different time zones seeking support at all hours, improving satisfaction and response rate.

3. Cost reduction

• Use case: AI tools can automate routine interactions, reducing the need for large customer support teams and minimizing overhead costs related to salaries, training, and office space.
• Example: AI tools can manage high volumes of inquiries simultaneously, particularly around busy periods like Black Friday and the lead up to the holidays.
• Benefit: Implementing AI can be an expensive upfront cost but should lead to cost reductions in the long term.

4. Scalability

• Use case: AI systems can handle increasing volumes of inquiries seamlessly without requiring additional resources.
• Example: A rapidly growing scaleup or business experiencing seasonal spikes can use AI-powered solutions like chatbots or automated ticketing systems to manage workloads efficiently.
• Benefit: This scalability ensures that you can maintain a high level of service, without needing to rapidly hire and train new employees.

5. Personalization through data analysis

• Use case: AI’s ability to analyze customer behavior and preferences is a game-changer for personalization.
• Example: An AI-powered recommendation engine might suggest products based on a customer’s previous purchases or browsing patterns, enhancing their shopping experience and boosting sales.
• Benefit: This level of personalization fosters customer loyalty and creates a more engaging interaction.

6. Consistency in service delivery

• Use case: Unlike human agents, who may have varying performance levels due to factors like fatigue, stress, or mood, AI delivers a consistent service.
• Example: An AI chatbot can provide standardized troubleshooting steps for technical issues, ensuring no crucial details are missed.
• Benefit: Customers can expect the same accurate and timely responses regardless of when or how they interact with the system, building trust and sense of dependability in the brand.

7. Multilingual support

• Use case: Language barriers can be a significant challenge in customer service, particularly for businesses with an international customer base.
• Example: AI-powered systems equipped with natural language processing, like Google’s Natural Language AI, can provide support in multiple languages. This makes it easier for customers to communicate their needs.
• Benefit: Translation services or multilingual chatbots allow businesses to serve a diverse audience without the need for a large, multilingual support team — cost-effectively ensuring accessibility and inclusivity.

8. Data collection and insights

• Use case: AI systems assist with immediate customer needs and gather and analyze valuable data from interactions. These insights can reveal trends, identify recurring issues, and highlight areas for improvement in the customer experience.
• Example: If an AI system detects a large volume of inquiries related to delayed shipments, the business can investigate and address the root cause.
• Benefit: These insights also help refine marketing strategies and personalize future interactions, making AI a vital tool for long-term business growth.

Key disadvantages of AI in customer service

While AI has revolutionized customer service with its efficiency and scalability, it is not without its risks. Here’s a more detailed look at the key disadvantages you should consider before investing:

1. Lack of human empathy

• Limitation: AI struggles to replicate human agents’ emotional intelligence and empathy during customer interactions. This limitation becomes particularly apparent in sensitive or emotionally charged situations.
• Example: A customer calling to report a lost loved one’s account or seeking help with a personal crisis may require genuine compassion, which AI cannot offer.
• Disadvantage: Generic responses from an AI system can come across as impersonal or dismissive, leaving customers feeling unsupported and frustrated.

2. Challenges with complex or unique queries

• Limitation: These systems rely on predefined algorithms and datasets, making it difficult for them to address nuanced issues that fall outside their programming, like strangely worded or unique queries.
• Example: An AI chatbot may struggle to resolve a billing dispute involving multiple accounts or provide a satisfactory answer to a highly technical query.
• Disadvantage: Customers may need to repeat their issues to a human agent, increasing frustration and prolonging the resolution process.

3. High initial costs

• Limitation: Implementing AI solutions can involve significant upfront costs, making it a challenging investment for small and medium-sized businesses.
• Example: Businesses need to account for purchasing software, integrating it with existing systems, and training AI models with large and diverse datasets. Additionally, ongoing maintenance, updates, and troubleshooting can add to the overall cost.
• Disadvantage: Smaller organizations may struggle to recoup their initial investment quickly.

4. Risk of errors and misinterpretation

• Limitation: AI systems rely on algorithms to interpret customer inputs, and they’re not immune to errors or misunderstandings. Ambiguous language, slang, or typos can cause AI to misinterpret a query and provide an irrelevant or incorrect response.
• Example: A customer asking, “How do I cancel my subscription?” might receive a response detailing how to change their subscription plan instead.
• Disadvantage: Errors can frustrate customers and erode their confidence in the service.

5. Customer frustration with automation

• Limitation: Many customers prefer interacting with human agents, especially when dealing with sensitive or urgent matters. Rigid AI systems that repeatedly offer irrelevant or unhelpful responses can lead to customer frustration.
• Example: An automated phone system that endlessly loops through menu options without connecting the caller to a human agent can leave customers feeling ignored.
• Disadvantage: This dissatisfaction is often amplified when there’s no clear option to escalate an issue to a live representative.

6. Data privacy concerns

• Limitation: AI systems in customer service often rely on collecting and processing large amounts of customer data to function effectively. While this data enables personalization and insights, it also raises significant privacy and security concerns.
• Example: A chatbot used by an e-commerce company may store customer payment details for future purchases, which cybercriminals could gain access to.
• Disadvantage: Businesses must ensure compliance with data protection regulations like GDPR or CCPA and safeguard against potential data breaches. A security lapse could result in sensitive customer information being exposed, leading to a loss of trust and legal ramifications.

7. Limited adaptability

• Limitation: AI systems are programmed to operate within specific parameters, making them less adaptable to unexpected scenarios or evolving customer needs.
• Example: If a business changes its policies or launches a new product, AI tools may require extensive updates and retraining to handle related customer inquiries.
• Disadvantage: This rigidity can hinder the system’s effectiveness and delay its ability to provide accurate responses in dynamic environments.

How to mitigate the disadvantages of AI in customer service

To overcome these challenges, you should combine the strengths of AI with human expertise — this way, you can create an optimal customer service experience:

• Blend AI with human support: To ensure a balanced approach, use AI for routine tasks while reserving complex queries for human agents.
• Regular performance monitoring: Continuously assess AI systems to identify errors and make necessary adjustments.
• Invest in training data: Use diverse and comprehensive datasets to improve AI’s ability to handle nuanced customer interactions.
• Focus on transparency: Clearly communicate how customer data is used and prioritize robust security measures to build trust.

AI has undoubtedly revolutionized customer service by offering speed, scalability, and cost-efficiency. But its lack of empathy, high initial costs, and data privacy concerns means a thoughtful implementation approach is needed.

Improve your customer service with Jotform

At Jotform, we’re testing ways we can make our new, and existing, AI tools more powerful. As part of this initiative, our AI Chatbot Builder offers an innovative solution to turn your website into an interactive experience. With advanced customization and training, instant responses, seamless form assistance, and customizable branding, it’s designed to align perfectly with your business needs. Whether it’s enhancing customer support for e-commerce or driving lead generation for real estate, our chatbot streamlines user engagement and maximizes efficiency.

Also, you can be the first to know when Jotform’s customer service agents are ready to hit the market when you join over 1000 others on the waitlist. And in the meantime, discover how our AI-backed online form builder can help you automate your customer journey and maximize operational efficiency — get started for free today, with no coding required.

Photo by MART PRODUCTION