The pros and cons of AI in recruitment

According to recent data from LinkedIn, 67 percent of hiring managers use AI tools in their talent acquisition strategies. As more companies integrate AI tools into the recruitment process, it’s important to understand their full impact, because they can have both powerful advantages and significant drawbacks. 

AI can streamline the recruitment process, but it can also unintentionally exclude well-qualified candidates if the technology or underlying data is flawed. As a result, companies are carefully weighing the benefits of recruitment automation against the potential risks, including AI hiring bias, data privacy concerns, and compliance with antidiscrimination laws.

In this post, we’ll walk through how organizations commonly use AI for recruitment, followed by a detailed breakdown of its pros and cons. Whether you’re an HR leader exploring AI-driven solutions or a business owner curious about the latest trends, this post can help you determine if machine learning in recruitment is the right fit for your company.

Jotform AI Agents

Build Your Custom AI Agent in Minutes

Get Started Now

How AI is used in recruitment

For many organizations, the promise of shorter time-to-hire windows, more accurate candidate screening, and reduced recruiting costs makes AI a compelling solution to modern hiring challenges. Rather than manually wading through hundreds or even thousands of applications, recruiting teams can rely on AI tools to prescreen résumés, schedule interviews, and assess candidates fit for specific roles.

Sourcing candidates

AI is integrated into multiple stages of the recruitment process, often through specialized software and platforms. One example is AI-driven hiring platforms that focus on sourcing candidates. These platforms proactively search job boards, social media, and professional networks to find potential candidates who match an organization’s needs — even if those individuals aren’t actively looking for a new role.

Screening candidates

One of the most common applications of AI in recruitment is the use of AI screening tools that rapidly scan résumés and cover letters for relevant keywords, work experience, and skill sets. By automating this initial filter, recruitment automation can help HR teams identify top candidates from a large applicant pool in a fraction of the time it usually takes.

Interacting with candidates

The rise of human resources AI agents, such as those featured in Jotform’s Human Resources AI Agents directory, has revolutionized how HR teams interact with potential hires. These AI assistants can handle many day-to-day interactions — from answering common candidate questions to guiding them through the application process. Jotform’s own Recruitment AI Agent and Recruitment Application AI Agent streamline the hiring process by collecting essential applicant information through dynamic, conversational forms.

Learning from the past

Beyond sourcing and screening, machine learning in recruitment enables tools to learn from past hiring decisions. For instance, an AI system notes whether an organization consistently hires candidates with specific educational backgrounds or skill sets who become top performers. It then prioritizes future applicants with similar profiles. This approach can help companies maintain a steady pipeline of high-quality candidates and reduce turnover.

All of these innovations highlight the versatility of AI in HR. Whether automating repetitive tasks like scheduling or using data analytics to find the perfect hire, AI is reshaping the recruitment landscape. However, it’s crucial to know how these tools operate to avoid pitfalls like unintentional bias or over-automation. In the following sections, we’ll examine the key benefits that AI brings to the table — and the challenges it can introduce.

Pros of AI in recruitment

Below are some of the most significant advantages of incorporating AI and automation into your hiring process. When deployed thoughtfully, these benefits can transform your talent acquisition strategy.

Increased efficiency and speed

• Résumé screening automation: AI tools can quickly sift through large volumes of applications, identifying candidates who meet the job requirements. 
• Scheduling assistance: AI assistants and chatbots can handle routine tasks like scheduling interviews, enabling recruiters to focus on more strategic activities such as one-on-one candidate interactions or assessing organizational culture fit.
• Streamlined conversations: Human resources AI agents can provide real-time support to candidates, answering FAQs and guiding them through the application process without requiring a recruiter’s direct involvement.

Reduced bias (when implemented correctly)

• Algorithmic decision-making: When AI is trained on diverse, high-quality datasets, it can avoid some of the unconscious biases that plague human decision-making. Instead of focusing on a candidate’s name or background, AI screening tools zero in on the essential skills and qualifications needed for the role.
• Fairer candidate pools: AI can highlight applicants who traditional methods might have overlooked. Suppose a system is programmed to emphasize skill sets and experiences. In that case, it may promote more diverse candidates who excel in those areas but lack conventional markers like an Ivy League degree.
• Ongoing auditing: Companies can periodically assess the AI’s decisions by analyzing demographic data on who advances and who gets rejected, identifying patterns that might indicate AI biases creeping into the system.

Cost savings

• Lower recruitment spend: Businesses can reduce the labor hours required from their recruitment teams by automating time-consuming tasks. According to the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM), the average cost-per-hire can reach up to $4,700. AI can minimize these costs by handling initial candidate screening and routine communications.
• Improved resource allocation: Fewer resources can be funneled into manual tasks, allowing HR staff to focus on high-impact activities like relationship building, data analysis, and strategic planning.
• Faster time-to-hire: Efficient processes lead to fewer delays, which means you can fill roles more quickly. 

Enhanced candidate experience

• Instant engagement: Chatbots and AI assistants respond to candidate inquiries immediately, setting expectations about timelines and next steps. Quick communication can significantly reduce candidate drop-off rates.
• Personalized interactions: AI-driven systems can adapt messaging based on a candidate’s profile or stage, creating more tailored experiences that engage talent.
• Convenient application process: Conversational forms allow applicants to easily submit details and find answers without navigating multiple portals.

Better quality of hires

• Data-driven insights: AI doesn’t rely on gut feelings or anecdotal evidence. By analyzing large datasets related to performance, turnover, and skill gaps, AI helps identify candidates who best match the role’s requirements.
• Predictive analytics: Some systems use machine learning to correlate past hires’ success factors — such as work experience, specific competencies, and even cultural indicators — with prospective candidates, improving the likelihood of selecting top performers.
• Performance tracking: Once hires are made, AI can track performance metrics over time, refining its algorithm to become even more accurate in future searches.

AI’s ability to automate labor-intensive tasks, reduce certain types of bias, and provide actionable analytics makes it an attractive proposition for many organizations. However, the technology is far from perfect. As we’ll explore below, there are also notable drawbacks that companies must consider before diving headfirst into AI-driven hiring.

Cons of AI in recruitment

Despite its potential, AI is not a one-size-fits-all solution. Below are key challenges and risks that can arise when you incorporate AI into your recruitment process.

Potential AI hiring bias

• Inherited data bias: If the data used to train AI models contains historical biases — such as hiring records that favor a particular gender or ethnicity — the system may inadvertently perpetuate these inequalities.
• Lack of transparency: Many AI solutions operate as “black boxes,” making it hard for HR teams to understand exactly how they arrive at their recommendations. This lack of clarity can hide subtle biases.
• Mitigation strategies: Regular audits and diverse training data are essential for reducing the risk of discriminatory outcomes. Some businesses also hire third-party experts to evaluate their AI systems for hidden AI bias.

Limitations in evaluating human qualities

• Soft skills and cultural fit: AI can parse résumés and match keywords, but it struggles to accurately gauge intangible qualities like emotional intelligence, teamwork, or growth mindset.
• Risk of overreliance: If companies depend too heavily on AI recommendations, they might overlook candidates who excel in less quantifiable areas or have unconventional backgrounds that don’t neatly match predefined algorithms.
• Human touch: Recruiting is fundamentally about relationships. While AI can expedite preliminary steps, human judgment remains crucial to determining whether a candidate will mesh well with the company’s culture and long-term vision.

Data privacy concerns

• Extensive data collection: AI solutions often gather large quantities of applicant information, including work histories, social media data, and even video recordings. Storing and processing such data raises complex privacy issues.
• Regulatory compliance: European laws, such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), impose strict requirements on how companies collect, store, and use personal data. Noncompliance can result in significant financial penalties and reputational damage.
• Security risks: Any centralized database is a potential target for hackers. A breach can expose sensitive candidate data, damage trust, and trigger legal repercussions.

Dependence on high-quality data

• Garbage in, garbage out: AI models are only as good as the data they analyze. Incomplete or biased datasets can lead to misguided hiring decisions and a narrow talent pool.
• Continuous updates needed: Market conditions, skill demands, and organizational priorities change over time. AI tools require ongoing maintenance and data updates to stay relevant and practical.
• Data management costs: Gathering, cleaning, and updating large datasets can be resource-intensive. Smaller companies or those with limited data might struggle to fully leverage AI’s capabilities.

Legal and ethical risks

• Antidiscrimination laws: Companies must ensure that AI-driven hiring doesn’t violate local or national regulations prohibiting discrimination based on race, gender, or age. If AI practices are found discriminatory, employers can face lawsuits and fines.
• Ethical dilemmas: Automated screening can sometimes feel impersonal. If AI tools handle most interactions, candidates might perceive the process as dehumanizing, potentially harming your employer’s brand.
• Lack of clear guidelines: As AI in HR is relatively new, many regions lack comprehensive legal frameworks. This legal “gray area” means companies must adopt careful policies and transparent practices to avoid unforeseen challenges.

Recognizing these potential pitfalls is the first step toward using AI responsibly. You can strike a balance that leverages the best of both worlds by pairing AI with human insight and continuously monitoring and refining your algorithms.

Is AI in recruitment right for my organization?

So is AI-driven hiring right for you? The answer depends on your needs, data readiness, and risk tolerance. Without proper oversight, AI-based tools can perpetuate existing inequalities or fail to capture the intangible human qualities that determine whether someone thrives in a given role. However, AI-driven hiring can also increase efficiency, reduce certain biases, cut costs, and enhance the candidate experience. 

If you opt to explore AI solutions:

• Start small: Pilot an AI-based screening or scheduling tool on a single team or department. Gather feedback from both candidates and recruiters before rolling out organization-wide.
• Audit and monitor: Regularly review the performance of your AI systems for signs of bias or inaccuracies. Make data ethics and transparency guiding principles in your AI adoption.
• Maintain human oversight: Use AI to assist rather than replace human recruiters. Ensure final hiring decisions account for soft skills, culture fit, and other human-centered considerations.

Innovate in HR by harnessing the power of AI

The pros and cons of AI in recruitment illustrate a rapidly evolving landscape filled with promise and caution. Organizations that use machine learning in recruitment effectively often find they can fill positions faster, improve the quality of their hires, and free up human recruiters to focus on strategic, relationship-building tasks. On the other hand, technology is not without challenges. Potential pitfalls, such as AI hiring bias, data privacy issues, and overreliance on automated evaluations, can undermine the benefits. 

In a highly competitive and data-rich talent acquisition world, AI offers an exciting opportunity to streamline and upgrade traditional HR practices. However, striking a balance between automation and human empathy remains crucial. By combining the strengths of AI with the nuanced judgment of experienced recruiters, you can build an innovative and equitable hiring process, ultimately positioning your organization to attract and retain the best possible talent.

Photo by: pch.vector